Fabricated Evidences and Subversion: Unmasking the Instrumental Role in Creating Unrest

The Shopian Conspiracy and the Unprecedented Threat to Justice and Peace in Kashmir

Thirteen years after an investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation ruled out rape of two women in south Kashmir’s Shopian, and chargesheeted 13 persons for fabricating evidence, in the annals of criminal justice, few cases have exposed the depths of subversion and the perils of fabricated evidence as profoundly as the Shopian tragedy in Kashmir. The recent termination of Dr. Bilal Ahmad Dalal and Dr. Nighat Shaheen Chilloo from their government positions serves as a stark reminder of the insidious forces at play, orchestrating unrest by exploiting the vulnerabilities of societal and governmental institutions.

The Shopian episode stands as a classic textbook case study, illuminating the sinister tactics employed by Pakistan and its proxies within Jammu and Kashmir. These vested interests mobilized their deep assets to fabricate an entirely false narrative, with the ultimate aim of tarnishing the Indian state’s image. Dr. Bilal and Dr. Nighat were instrumental players in this web of deception, acting as key conduits to achieve the objective of disaffection against the Indian state.

Their manipulative scheme centered around falsifying the post-mortem report of Asiya and Neelofar, two unfortunate victims who tragically lost their lives in an accidental drowning incident on May 29, 2009. These doctors, allegedly working in collusion with Pakistan’s ISI and terrorist outfits, went to extreme lengths to undermine the truth and justice. By falsely accusing security forces of rape and murder, they aimed to ignite widespread disaffection, resulting in social unrest and a loss of faith in the government.

The impact of their conspiracy was devastating. The aftermath of the Shopian incident saw the Kashmir valley engulfed in flames for a prolonged period of seven months, from June to December 2009. During this time, strike calls orchestrated by groups like Hurriyat punctuated the air, inciting widespread rioting and lawlessness. The consequences were dire, with a staggering 600 minor and major law and order incidents reported across all districts of the valley. Lives were lost, injuries inflicted, and both civilians and security personnel bore the brunt of the chaos.

The economic repercussions were equally severe, with an estimated loss of few thousand crores worth of business during those turbulent months. The consequences of the fabricated evidences and subversion unleashed in the Shopian case cast a long shadow, the effects of which persisted well into the following year. The very foundations of justice and peace in Kashmir were undermined, leaving scars that still haunt the region.

Uncovering the truth behind the Shopian conspiracy has shed light on the immense challenges faced by the justice system in combating subversion and falsehoods. It reveals the lengths to which external influences will go to erode public trust and sow discord. The fact that high-ranking individuals in the government were aware of these malicious activities, yet chose to bury the truth, is a painful reminder of the compromises made at the expense of justice.

Now, as the termination of Dr. Bilal and Dr. Nighat sends a powerful message, we must remain vigilant. The Shopian case serves as a clarion call for all stakeholders involved in the pursuit of truth and justice. It demands a comprehensive review of the mechanisms in place to prevent and expose such conspiracies. Only by unmasking these elements and holding them accountable can we safeguard the integrity of our institutions and restore faith in the pursuit of justice.

Kashmir, a land of immense beauty and resilience, deserves a future free from the shadows of fabricated evidence and subversion. Let us come together to ensure that the Shopian tragedy stands as a turning point, a testament to our resolve in upholding justice, truth, and lasting peace.



2 / 2

Leave a Reply